Readings

Susan and I made our fortnightly pilgrimage to our local library yesterday. I had books to return, books to pick up, Susan had books to find.

While she checked through the catalogue, I browsed through the stacks. I rambled, stopping now and again to pull a book down and read the first page, the opening paragraphs, flip a few pages in – sometimes less than a hundred, sometimes more – and read again.

I spent some thirty minutes thus engaged. Probably opened 12-15 books.

Not a single book engaged me.

I selected the books at random. If a selection criteria existed, it existed non-consciously.

Walking out of the library, I said to Susan, “I can’t get over how many books are genuinely poorly written. And these got published?”

You don’t want me to review your book
A publisher sent me a book they’d published. I said upfront that I wouldn’t review it unless I thought it a good book.

I won’t be reviewing it.

I read the first paragraph and stopped. I read it to Susan. She thought it okay. I rewrote it. “Definitely better,” she said.

Basically I took a block of exposition and turned it into dialogue laced with action. Instead of being told what’s going on, the reader gets to hear, see, and feel it happening.

I wanted to contact the publisher. “You really published this book? What you sent me was after editing? What are sales like?”

(they’re better than mine, it’s been out longer than mine. not sure it makes a difference)

But the writing? Sucked.

Then I reread for the umpteenth time…
I spent my Sunday afternoon on my backporch watching the wind in the trees, sipping a good single-malt Scotch — neat. Water on the side — smoking a good cigar, and listening to music spanning Artie Traum, Rick Wakeman, Prince, World Party, Robert Palmer, Nick Lowe, Pentagle, Pippin, and you get the idea. Varied.

 
All of which served as background to Riders of the Purple Sage. On every page I wanted to share the writing.

Powerful, wonderful, elegant, moving, intricate, delightful, evocative, meaningful writing. Writing that pulls you in, takes you into the story’s myth and keeps you there, weds you to the characters, locks your senses on to the happenings of the story, makes it more real than the heat of the Scotch or the draw of the cigar or the sweet of the water or the cool of the wind.

That’s what I want my writing to be. To do.

Let me know when I get there.

2 Responses

  1. da-AL says:

    but the crummy books that do well give me hope that there’s room for us all…

    • Joseph Carrabis says:

      I appreciate your optimism.
      The researcher in me wants to know the algorithm, though. I know professional publishing – whether indie/small press or major house – is subjective. Yes, there are market considerations and when all things are equal, subjective wins.
      It’s when I see something poorly written get major house published that I go “Huh?”
      And I also know I’m a tough judge.

      And thanks for reading and commenting. Muchly Appreciated!

Joseph Carrabis, Author Shopping Cart
I feel so empty...
Writing Mentoring


Interested in taking your writing to the next level? Want to take a class with other writers and authors perfecting their craft?
Check out Writing Mentoring.
Classes are held on Wednesdays. Each session starts the first Wednesday of the month and ends the last Wednesday of the month. Morning and evening classes available.

Are you a Member? Would you like to be?
Subscribers! Want to be Interviewed?
Sorry, this content is available to paying subscribers only


Watch previous interviews to learn what they’re like.

History
Tagalicious
About Me Americana Analytics Ecology Anthropology A Tale of the Northern Clan Atmosphere attr Author Interviews Author Tools Bear Bees Behavior Betrayal Birds BizMediaScience Blurbs Bobcat Body-Mind-Spirit Book Blogs Character Childhood Trauma Children's Stories Chipmunk Conflict Cons-Fairs-Expos Contest Covers Coyote Cozy Murders Creative Non-Fiction Crime Comedy Crime Thrillers Critiques Crow Curses Cymodoce Deer Description Dialogue Economy of Meaning Editing Emotions Empty Sky Espionage Expanded Awareness Experiments in Writing Exposition Fains I Fantasy Fiction Flash Fox Gable Smiled Gel Ink and Rollberball Gender Gothic Romance Great Opening Lines Hanging Tree Harvey Duckman Hawk Heal History Horror Humor I'm Identity iMedia Interpersonal Relationships Jerry and Betty know Language Learnings Library of Congress Life Linguistics Literature Lively Discussions Lizard Love Story Magic Realism Marke Marketing Mayhem Midnight Garden Midnight Oil Midnight Roost Military Mood Music Mystery Myth Narration Neuroscience Newsletters Noir Non-Fiction Old Ones Opossum Owl Pace Performance Artist Personal Finance Personal Improvement Personality Philosophy Pitch Plot Podcast Poetry POV Psychology Rabbit Rabbit Hole 5 Rabbit Hole 6 Rabbit Hole 7 Rabbit Hole 8 Raccoons Readings Recovery Triptych Relationships Reviews Revision Ritchie and Phyl Rob and Joan Carter Romance RoundTable Scenes Science Fiction Search Self-Discovery Self-Help Setting Skunk Snake Social Sociology Spider Spies Spirituality Spoken Word Sports Stating the Obvious StoryCrafting StoryTelling Structure Style SubStack Susan Tag Tales of the Woods