Natalie Goldberg’s Writing Down the Bones is not a book for everybody. I’m not sure how many authors, writers, and author-wannabes will take to it.
Did I take to it?
Oh, yes. But I’ve studied mystical traditions, perform regular meditation, and enjoy learning different teaching methods.
There are good exercises in the book and they’re really about learning about yourself as a writer, not about being a writer, not about writing better.
I’d offer that Goldberg’s primary focus is you being better at being yourself writing, not necessarily writing better. Consider it “Zen and the Art of Writing.” It even has an endorsement by Robert Persig, author of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance on the back (another book I recommend for self-discovery. Or reading about someone else’s self-discovery).
The chapters are short. The longest is just under five pages. The average length is probably 2.5 pages. There are no “conjugate verbs this way” or “the best form of the participle clause is…” What there are are beautiful suggestions and insights into the writing life.
Long ago and far away I self-published Reading Virtual Minds V1: History and Science (trade-technical). Left-brained thinkers hated it. Right-brained thinkers loved it. It didn’t explain how to do things (left-brain), it explained how things were done (right-brain) and invited readers to decide if they wanted to learn how to get things done or just do them.
Writing Down the Bones is much the same kind of book; it’s not about doing it, it’s about getting it done.
Personally, learn how it’s done. Once you’ve done that, you’ll know how to do it.